Skip to main content
Shelter operations resource

Adoption follow-up checklist

Decide before the adoption happens who will check in afterward, what they will ask, and where the answers are written down.

Follow-up is often the first thing dropped when intake gets busy. This checklist makes it a named task with an owner instead of a good intention.

Bring one workflow
01

Set the plan at adoption

  • Tell the adopter that someone will check in, who that person is, and roughly when.
  • Confirm the best way to reach the adopter and the days or times that suit them.
  • Write the follow-up dates into the record or calendar at the time of adoption, not later.
  • Name the staff member or volunteer who owns each follow-up.
Follow-up owner
Planned check-in dates
02

Questions to ask at a check-in

Open questions get fuller answers than yes or no questions. Write down what the adopter says in their own words.

  • How are the first days and weeks going? What has been easier or harder than expected?
  • What routines have you settled into, and what is still unsettled?
  • Is there anything about the animal you were not told or would have liked to know?
  • Has the animal seen a veterinarian yet? Is there any paperwork or record you are still waiting for from us?
  • Is there anything we could do to help, or any resource you would like us to point you to?
What the adopter said
Anything we promised to send
03

Records and paperwork

  • Confirm the adopter received the records your organization gives at adoption.
  • Confirm any microchip registration or contact update that is part of your process.
  • Update the animal's record with the outcome and the date of each follow-up.
  • Note anything that would change how a similar animal is described or matched next time.
Records confirmed
Record updated by
04

If the placement is not working

  • Make sure the adopter knows, in plain words, how to contact the organization if they are struggling.
  • Offer the resources your organization actually has, and say clearly when it does not have one.
  • Describe the return or rehoming process before it is needed, including who decides and what the adopter should do first.
  • Record the reason for a return in the adopter's words, so the next profile can be more specific.
Who the adopter calls
Return process owner
05

Close the loop

  • Decide when follow-up is complete and record that date.
  • Review the notes monthly for patterns: the same question, the same missing item, the same delay.
  • Change one thing in the adoption process based on what the follow-ups show.
Follow-up complete on
One change to make

Common questions

How many follow-ups should we do?
There is no single right number. Choose a schedule your team can actually keep, write it down, and keep to it. A smaller schedule that happens is better than a larger one that does not.
Does this checklist predict whether an adoption will succeed?
No. It helps your team ask consistent questions and record the answers. It does not rate or score adopters or animals.

Early access, founder-led

Keep this with the animal record.

WhiskerMatch is one record per animal that intake, foster, adoption review, and public profiles share. It starts with one workflow, beside the tools you already use, and a person at your organization makes every decision.

$20/month per organization, no seat limits. This is a founder-led early access invitation with no deadline. Writing to ask a question costs nothing and commits you to nothing.

Want to look first? Walk through the guided demo.